In January, 7 Seneca Road in Sea Ranch Lakes sold for $9 million to Florida Panthers forward Sam Reinhart, according to The Real Deal. The seller was Sergio Busquets, who joined Inter Miami in 2023. The sale closed about three months after the house was listed, $800,000 under its $9.8 million ask. Busquets's 2023 purchase of the house, at $8.7 million, was a community record at the time, according to The Real Deal's reporting that year. The house was built in 2023 on 0.3 acres, with 7,100 square feet and 100 feet of frontage on Lake Seneca.
Three months before Reinhart closed, a house a little farther down the same road sold for $13 million. Mansion Global reported that it has 7,000 square feet, was finished in 2025 and sits on a 0.31-acre lot. The two houses share a street and are close in age, size and lot area. They sold $4 million apart. The difference is the water behind them. The $13 million house is on the Intracoastal side of the village and faces Bay Colony.
The Line Most Sales Sit On
Sea Ranch Lakes is small enough that a few closings make up its whole market. The Real Deal describes the village as covering about 0.2 square miles, almost entirely walled, with its own police force and mayor, fewer than 200 homes and a private beach club. With so few sales, price per square foot is a better guide than a median.
Here are the single-family closings from March 2025 through July 2026. Per-foot figures are calculated from the reported sale price and living area.
- 44 Cayuga, no water frontage, $2,875,000 in March 2025, about $863 per square foot.
- 28 Minnetonka Road, 112 feet of Intracoastal frontage with a private dock, $7,735,470 in June 2025, about $1,244 per square foot.
- 7 Seneca Road, Lake Seneca frontage, $9,000,000 in January 2026, about $1,268 per square foot.
- 8 Oneida, no water frontage, $2,575,000 in January 2026, about $911 per square foot.
- 15 Minnetonka Road, no water frontage, $3,165,000 on July 6, 2026, about $994 per square foot.
- 4 Oneida Lane, no water frontage, $4,650,000 on July 31, 2026, about $1,275 per square foot.
Total prices on this list run from about $2.6 million to $9 million. Per-foot prices sit in a much tighter band. The lakefront house on Seneca, the Intracoastal house at 28 Minnetonka and the dry-lot house on Oneida Lane all closed between about $1,244 and $1,275 per square foot. Lake frontage and dry lots trade at about the same rate per foot. The lake buyer paid more in total because the house was larger.
Against that band, the $13 million Seneca Road sale in October 2025 works out to about $1,857 per square foot. That is roughly 45 percent above the cluster. The 2025 sales show two conditions together at the top of the market, Intracoastal water and a newly built house. An older Intracoastal home in June 2025 closed in the same band as the rest of the village. A 2023 house on the lake did too. The premium appeared when both conditions were met.
What the Lot Cost Before the House
The $13 million house shows how much of its price was land. According to Mansion Global, the seller, a local agent and developer, bought the lot for $3.875 million in 2022 and demolished the house on it to build new. The land was a little under 30 percent of the final sale price.
A buyer looking at an older Intracoastal house in Sea Ranch Lakes can use that 2022 lot price as a reference point. A lot of the same size on the same side of the village, with a house that came down, sold below $4 million three years before the finished house closed at $13 million. Most of the gap paid for the house the developer built. When a buyer compares an older Intracoastal home with a new one, most of the price difference is the cost and time of building, because the land is a smaller share. The Indian Creek post on lot-to-finish pricing covers the same idea on a different island.
The Intracoastal side matters to buyers here because a boat can be kept behind the house. 28 Minnetonka had a private dock on its 112 feet of frontage. The current listing at 34 Minnetonka Road describes 113 feet of direct Intracoastal frontage and a 60,000-pound boat lift. Lake Seneca and Lake Cayuga give a house water views. Intracoastal frontage gives it a dock. Our Harbor Beach post on canal width and boat size explains why buyers price dockage separately from water views.
Asking Prices Have Run Ahead of Closings
Recent records have taken time to reach. Mansion Global reported that the Seneca Road house came on the market in June 2024 at $16.8 million and went through several price cuts. It was asking $14.4 million when it went under contract in early October 2025 and closed at $13 million. The closing price was about 23 percent below the first ask, and the house took more than a year to sell. 7 Seneca's $800,000 gap was about 8 percent of its ask.
The same pattern continues on the Intracoastal side. 19 Gatehouse Road was built in 2022 and has 80 feet of Intracoastal frontage. Its asking price was cut on September 2, 2026, from $11,990,000 to $11,495,000. The Real Deal reported in January that 34 Minnetonka Road was asking $20 million. That listing belongs to Tim Elmes. It is a 2024 build with 7,372 square feet.
MLS records show no single-family sale in Sea Ranch Lakes from August 1 through mid-November 2026, so the most recent closing on the list above is 4 Oneida Lane in July. Private sales do not show up in that count. A buyer this winter has an asking-price ladder above $11 million and only one Intracoastal new-construction closing to compare it with, the $13 million record from October 2025. A seller in that position has the same single comparable sale.
Inter Miami's Matches Moved. Its Training Did Not.
In 2023, agents told The Real Deal that athletes were drawn to Sea Ranch Lakes by its walls, its guarded entrance and its own police force, and by how close it is to Inter Miami's stadium and training facilities. In 2026 the stadium part changed. According to MLS, Inter Miami's last match at the Fort Lauderdale venue long known as Chase Stadium was March 18, and home matches moved to the 26,700-seat Nu Stadium in Miami. The same report says the club will keep permanent training facilities at the Fort Lauderdale site for its senior team, its MLS NEXT Pro side and its academy.
The training ground is still in Fort Lauderdale, and a purchase since the move sits directly across the Intracoastal from Sea Ranch Lakes. In September 2026, the Miami Herald reported a deed showing that Sadani LLC paid $8 million for a house on Compass Lane in Bay Colony, next door to Lionel Messi's home. The Real Deal identified the property as 71 Compass Lane, with 7,660 square feet and 160 feet of frontage. It reported that Sadani LLC is managed by the person who has managed Messi's private investment firm, and that the same entity acquired 91 Compass Lane in 2023. The Real Deal also said it is unclear whether Messi is the beneficiary of the new purchase.
Mansion Global called the $13 million Seneca Road house a new price point for the stretch of the Intracoastal that Messi calls home. The athlete buyers here have never come from one club. In 2023, an agent active in the village told The Real Deal, "We've had NFL players, NBA players, race car drivers, executives," and the house's 2026 buyer plays in the NHL.
For a buyer comparing Sea Ranch Lakes with the gated communities across the water, the sales give a working rule. Lake homes, dry-lot homes and older Intracoastal homes have closed at about $1,250 per square foot or less since early 2025. Only a new house on the Intracoastal side has closed well above that, and only once. The current listings above $11 million are pricing their homes against that one sale.
To compare a specific Seneca, Minnetonka or Gatehouse address with these closings, Elmes Group can review the sale history, frontage and build year of each house next to the one you are considering. Contact Us to start that comparison.